I and some other scholars debate this question tomorrow on the forum: ARGUMENTATIVE INDIANS.
I suppose I am the only non-Indian they have invited but tomorrow will be an interesting exchange of views with Indian counterparts.
Timing: 12.30 UK Time; 13.30 Swedish Time; 16.30 Pakistan Time; 17.00 Indian Time.
You all can watch LIVE the discussion/debate tomorrow on: (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XpX0mZ3vhLE).